How often do they get it wrong

Hi all

 

I am new to this forum but not to breast ca. Had it 15 years ago. Found another lump in exactly the same place as the last one and the consultant radiologist seemed sure it was cancer. But can they really tell? trying to say to myself that only the biosyies will tell us for sure . I guess what i am asking is has anyone had a situation where the consultant is sure it is and it turns out not to be. Just would like to have some hope still. Or am I just dreaming.

 

 

  • Hi,

     

    You are absolutely right. The radiologist can only express a professional opinion and say what the probability is in his or her opinion. Until a biopsy is done, and your consultant oncologist has given you a formal diagnosis, no-one can be 100% sure of what that diagnosis will be. 

     

    The radilogist may well be right, but it was unprofessional to express an opinion at such an early stage of the process.

     

    Good luck!

    Dave

  • Hello Davek,

                       not so sure l fully agree with all your comments,yes the consdultant will give the absolute confirmation,but the radiologist is part of his MDT,is a professional with a concentrated knowledge from observing and interpreting the scan pictures.As part of the MDT team he will have given this opinion with the full approval of the team,to allow the patient the time to accept the likelyhood,avoid weeks of what if stress before seeing the consultant,and upon doing so be in a calmer state so as to take the information of future treatment on board and understand the implications.

                                                                                                                                  Do not lose sight they were not confirming cancer,just pointing towards the likelyhood,and allowing the patient the chance to sort out their possible position.l would say the radiologist would not have offered this opinion if there was any doubt

                                                                  So many people post of their incredible stress waiting for an answer and the not knowing is destructive,so surely this approach is designed to keep avoidable stress to a minimum,

                             just saying,

                                               David

  •  

    Hi LRec,

    Welcome to our forum. I was in your position 6 months after I  first had a lumpectomy. I found a large lump in my other breast. My consultant was pretty sure that it was cancer, but fortunately, it proved to be benign after biopsy.

    I then found another lump in my original breast, almost a year to the anniversary of my first diagnosis. I wasn't so lucky this time around. However, I'm still here 11 years on.

    It really is a lottery until you get the results of your biopsy.

    Please let us know how your results turn out. We are always here for you.

    I have my fingers crossed for good results.

    Kind regards,

    Jolamine xx

  • Thanks for your replies looks like they can get it wrong then shall just have to ride it out until next Wed.  Just wonder why they frighten you by talking about surgery etc would rather not have that information  until they were sure.