Melanoma stage 3C, NHS won't pay for treatment?

Hi everyone!

My husband was diagnosed with stage 3B melanoma in 2022. He had it removed from his right hand and one node in right armpit. He then started the BRAF targeted therapy in 2023 but stopped after a month or so because of side effects and becase the oncologist told him the benefit of it wasn't worth it.

Fast forward 3.5 years later, his melanoma came back in the lymph node and it's now stage 3C. However, the oncologist said because he already used treatment for "the same cancer", the NHS won't cover adjuvant treatment (in his case immunotherapy) for the second time. She said for him to get immunotherapy, it would need to progress to stage 4.

This just feels bizarre and really counterintuitive? He stopped targeted therapy because of the side effects and at the advice of his oncologist. It also feels wild that he can't get any treatment at all when the onvologist referred him for it. Has anyone else experienced this? We don't have private Healthcare to fall back on. 

  • Hello coolbeans

    Your poor husband to find himself in this position. NICE the authority that regulate and approve drugs for use in NHS do have some odd regulations on prescribing drugs. Especially expensive immunotherapy drugs like pembrolizumab and nivolumab where cost to health outcome are taken into consideration. Im currently receiving cemiplimab 3 weekly for advanced skin cancer. Cost outside NHS is £4500 per dose while NHS get it slightly cheaper. I had to stop taking it for 2 months due to my immune system being over stimulated then resume it again. Had the break gone over 12 weeks then NICE rules that I cannot restart it. In 3 months my treatment will stop as I will have reached the 2 years maximum allowed regardless of the fact that the drug is giving me a good quality life and keeping the cancer stable. I suppose that NICE have to ration drugs as there is not an unlimited amount of money available. For most people self funded immunotherapy at £100k per year is not an option other than selling your house. I really do feel for your husband not getting treatment earier as I worry about my treatment ending.

    Ed

  • Hi  thank you for your kind response and so sorry to hear you are experiencing this. I can't get over the fact that we are so lucky to live in a time when ground-breaking treatments like these are possible and yet not have access to them. It's beyond devastating. And aside from the ethics of it, it also doesn't make much financial sense for the NHS to wait for people to get worse in order to treat them. Surely, it's more expensive in the long-term this way.

    Has your oncology team told you what the next steps are once you're off cemiplimab? Is long-term remission on the cards?

  • Hello coolbeans

    Yes I agree with you it seems counter intuitive to wait until your husbands cancer is more advanced before precribing immunotherapy. Surly earlier treatment would give a better outcome. I wonder if a different oncologist would determine his cancer at à more advanced stage. For me there is no further treatment available. Ive had radiotherapy and much surgery. The cemiplimab immunotherapy is palliative. Im told there is an enduring effect from it once treatment ends as it trains the immune system to recognise cancer. So Im told by the oncologist that although the cancer is incurable there is a significant chance of long  term remission. And that hope keeps me going. I do hope that your husband is given the chance to have one of these amazing immunotherapy drugs. 

    Ed