Breast Cancer Surgery decisions - I'm really struggling to choose

I need to make a choice about surgery, mastectomy with implant in one breast or Diep reconstruction aagain for one breast. I am really struggling to choose as one is a longer surgery and recovery but I don’t like the idea of implant having silicone inside me. I’ve read so much information and it hasn’t helped. My Gp said with implants it lumps form behind then wouldn’t be able feel when examining myself is this true.

Thank you 

  • Hello and thanks for your enquiry,

    I can appreciate it can be difficult deciding on your breast surgery options, and it does depend on personal preference. You haven't mentioned as to whether you have had the opportunity to talk this over with your hospital breast care nurse. They are best placed to talk it through with you, being directly involved with your clinical care.

    Women with breast implants can be physically examined, and also have mammograms done, so I am not sure what your GP was referring to. Current NHS breast surgical techniques place implants in a way that keeps the chest wall and remaining chest and breast skin easy to examine.

    After a mastectomy, most breast tissue is removed. Should a breast cancer return in the local area of the original surgery, it almost always develops in the skin flaps, along the scar, or in the armpit. Because these areas sit on top of the implant, these can be felt with an examination.

    Also because a DIEP flap uses your own abdominal fat, it is common to develop harmless, firm lumps called fat necrosis or oil cysts as the transferred tissue heals. While benign, these are checked with NHS ultrasound scans that help to confirm they are not cancer.

    It is about deciding between a bigger surgery, and a longer recovery period afterwards. Some women can have a mastectomy and then leave the option open for a DIEP reconstruction a year or two later.

    You may find it helpful to contact the UK charity breastcancernow They have patients that are trained volunteers and can be contacted to share their experiences of having had one of these options. Sometimes one can find this helpful, in reaching a personal decision that is right for them.

    I hope that this helps,

    Best wishes,

    Vanda