I think my sister is lying about her cancer...

Hi there,

My 26 year old sister has been suffering from bowel and stomach cancer for over a year now but certain things are actually making me question if she has cancer still or had it at all. Here are a few things that don't add up:

She apparently has had an operation to remove her stomach and have it replaced with a bag (internally) I have triple checked with her that she didn't mean her bowels with a colostomy or ileostomy bag and she is adamant that it was her stomach with an internal bag. I have looked into this op and cannot find that it exists. She was also walking around a pumpkin patch and bending over a lot not even two days supposedly post op which I find hard to believe is possible that early on after major surgery.

Another is on multiple occasions she has told us she has sepsis but the doctors wont admit her for a few hours until the evening (we would be told this by her in the morning). I was under the impression (and have been told by NHS staff and people who have had sepsis) that any concern of sepsis and you are rushed in immediately because you could get septic shock and die. She would also be released 24 hours after (is this normal?).

One of the times she was meant to be in hospital with sepsis she was seen on a tractor lugging potatoes.

A bowel cancer nurse was telling me that it is quite rare for patients having chemo for just bowel cancer to lose their hair. We never actually saw my sister lose any hair, she just told us she was pulling out clumps (her hair was never patchy to indicate loss) and she elected to shave it so she wouldn't have to deal with the stress of hair loss (At the time she only had bowel cancer not stomach cancer and was only on chemo).

We have never taken her to hospital for treatments, we would offer but she told us an ambulance or nurse would pick her up from the house and drop her back off after treatment. On top of this sometimes the nurse would do chemo in her home. I have been at her home multiple times when the nurse was meant to visit and no nurse arrived, when I would point it out that the nurse hasn't come she would say that she and the nurse would text each other to rearrange. Is this not a waste of NHS resources? I've never heard of ambulances and nurses becoming taxi's before? And can chemo be done in a patients home?

She would also be sent home with injectable morphine, we never saw her inject herself but she did have needles and syringes. I work at a vets and we would NEVER give a controlled drug to members of the public to use! Is it different in human medication?

 

I would like to think (not in a bad way) that she did have cancer originally and that she hasn't lied about it from the office but I am strongly doubting that she still has it now. I don't know how to voice my concerns to the rest of my family because she is the 'golden child' and I honestly don't think they will believe me even if I explained all the inconsistencies to them. Is there a way I can find proof? Should I be hiring a private investigator? It makes me sad that she is quite literally taking advantage of this illness to get things out of people. Maybe I am wrong and if someone can logically explain all of these inconsistencies and how they could fit stomach and bowel cancer then I would 100% leave it and her be.

  • Hello and thanks for posting,

    We cannot comment emphatically on a person's actual situation, not being directly involved on a clinical level, and I cannot advise you about hiring a private investigator. That would need to be your decision.

    You could ask her directly to provide proof, as in medical records found on her NHS App, or by logging in to her GP surgery records to share with you.

    Somebody who has undergone major surgery, would usually be advised not to bend over, or do strenuous activity for 4 to 6 weeks post surgery.

    Much of this story does not appear to be consistent or very accurate, that is as much as we can say about it, without picking it apart.

    I hope that you manage to find out more, or resolve the situation soon. 

    Best wishes,

    Vanda

  • I hope you find some answers soon as this can't be a nice position for you to be in at all. Has she ever showed you any letters, documents, test results etc online or in person? I am going through testing for bowel cancer at the moment (and previously cervical cancer) and all tests you receive a clinic letter with the plan and what has been carried out etc. It would definitely be worth asking. Walking around two days post op also doesn't sound right as having that type of operation would require considerable recovery time. I've heard that people have to stay in hospital a couple of days after. It's hard to know with not knowing your sister but I think it would be worth trying to get to the bottom of it soon for you and your family but also for your sister as she will need help and support if she is feeling like she should lie about cancer, if she is. 

  • HelloTiredtoday,

                                as a recovered bowel cancer with spread to the liver patient,l think your sister definately does need quite alot of understanding but not concerning bowel or stomach cancer. As to why that would be is a ball firmly in your court, but good luck and tread gently,

                                                                                                                       David

  • Thank you for your response. Are you at least able to tell me whether (as far as you are aware) a procedure exists where your entire stomach is removed and replaced permanently by a bag? (Not colostomy or ileostomy but stomach). Or know any gastroenterologist information sites where I can look into this?

  • No, she will no longer speak to me and says she doesn't needsl to show me anything to prove she isn't lying, even depsite me saying that not providing evidence is even more suspicious and does nothing to dim down concerns. I explained that showing proof would make me look like a fool and prove she isn't making all of this up, instead I have been blocked on all medias. It would be nice to get to the bottom of it but sadly I don't think I will because she won't co-operate in easing doubts and no one else wants to believe that someone would lie about having cancer even despite the very dodgy details and evidence showing otherwise :/ 

  • Hello and thanks for getting back to us again. 

    I don't think that there is anything you can do if she does not want to tell you about her condition.  Hopefully with time she may be able to open up and explain her situation. 

    A gastrectomy (removal of a stomach) is a major operation which does take time to recover from. 

    I would respect her decision if she does not want to share her situation and as another cancer chat member suggested to tread carefully.

    All the Best,

    Catherine

  • I'm not a nurse or anything, but I've just had my bowel resection a week ago, I'm a 38year old healthy woman, and after 2 days I was still in a hospital bed high on morphine. Even now a week later, I can't lift anything heavier than half a kettle of water, can't bend all the way down or drive! I've never known of nurses coming to your home to do chemo, I know you can take tablets at home, which you do yourself, and a friend of mine did lose her hair from chemo for bowel cancer. I may have to have chemo also, and they did tell me it was a side effect. 
    my father in law had stomach cancer and was supposed to have his whole stomach removed. They don't put any kind of bag in there, they sow your intestines to your osophagus and it forms a sort of pouch that is used instead of the stomach. He couldn't have his done as when they opened him up, the cancer was worse than expected, but even just the wound they left was so painful he was bed ridden for some time after. I'd hate to think your sister is lying, but her story doesn't seem to make much sense